Uncle Angelo’s Eggnog

Uncle Angelo’s Eggnog Cocktail

Base Spirit: Bourbon / American Whiskey, Rum

Type: Classics, Punches

Served: Neat/Up

Preparation: Stirred

Strength: Medium

Difficulty: Medium

Flavor Profile: Creamy, Spirit-forward, Sweet

About the Uncle Angelo’s Eggnog Cocktail

You’ll be claiming Angelo as your own relative after just one sip of this delightful Eggnog recipe.

Ingredients in the Uncle Angelo’s Eggnog Cocktail

  • 6 Eggs, separated
  • .75 cup Sugar, divided
  • 1 qt (32 oz) Whole milk
  • 1 pt (16 oz) Heavy cream
  • 8 oz Bourbon (Four Roses)
  • 4 oz Spiced rum (Captain Morgan or Sailor Jerry)

Garnish: Grated nutmeg

Glass: Punch or tea cup

How to make the Uncle Angelo’s Eggnog Cocktail

In a large bowl, beat together the egg yolks and half a cup of sugar until they turn light in color. Stir in the milk, heavy cream, bourbon and rum. In a separate bowl, beat the egg whites with the remaining quarter-cup of sugar until they form soft peaks. Fold about a third of the egg whites into the yolk mixture. Serve in punch or tea cups topped with freshly grated nutmeg, folding in more of the egg whites as desired.

More Great Food & Drink Stories from Across the Web


  1. I serve a recipe just like this! Except using some heavy whipping cream instead of milk- going to try it will milk now though. Also, I make sure to buy pasteurized shell eggs. Drinking too much eggnog can already make you feel sick, lol, I don’t want to risk serving everyone at my holiday party a cup of salmonella.

  2. this site is so cool i really like it, i love the recipes to. The only thing that could make it better is to provide ebooks of the recipe’s free for download just in case someone does not have a printer.

  3. Thank you !


  1. […] Cocktail Calling all eggnog enthusiasts: you must try Uncle Angelo’s recipe for eggnog. This is way better than the store bought stuff: you’ll need separate eggs, sugar, whole milk, […]

Speak Your Mind

leaderboard bottom